@kdfrawg Both methods have their merits. I just wanted to make sure was clear these are different approaches.

@kdfrawg the problem with the Plurk approach is it doesn't handle conversational drift well. Root post starts on Topic X that I don't care about, becomes about Topic Y that I do. Plurk gives me no indication of Topic Y, only Topic X.

The Jaiku approach focused on current conversation with a link to the total thread. You could also mute the conversation as well (maybe something needs to implement anyway).

It seems like there should be some hybrid of the two approaches, though I'm not sure what that looks like, exactly.

@kdfrawg I think we're conflating two concepts here:

  1. Conversation view where you ONLY see the active conversations (a-la Plurk, but with some improvements).
  2. A timeline view where it's far easier to see a given post is part of a conversation (like what Jaiku did).

built the second thing, you're looking for the first.

I had a four day weekend, so I definitely need three. :P

//

I probably need three today. :P

not likely…

@thrrgilag on the plus side, we're that much closer to Friday.

Personally I'm not a fan of "only first posts" showing, but that's exactly what Plurk does.Unread count only would be good.

// @kdfrawg

I think the people in charge would like to remain so. If more people really knew what was going on, they'd revolt.

Looking through some screenshots, there is a visual difference between posts as part of a conversation and posts that start a conversation. It also doesn't show the origin/replied to post. You can kind of see that here: http://www.michele.me/blog/assets_c/2009/01/jaiku-stream-758.html

// @kdfrawg